Finding stylish, modest clothing in the heart of Lancaster, Pennsylvania is easier than you might think. Whether you prefer trendy skirts, handcrafted cape dresses, or budget-friendly basics, the shops below offer faith-friendly options for every wardrobe and wallet.
Browse Modest Clothing Stores in Lancaster
The Main Street Exchange
What Does This Store Provide:
This light-filled boutique curates on-trend skirts, dresses, and layering pieces in sizes XS–3X, proving modesty and style can walk hand-in-hand. Natural fibers and exclusive in-house designs make it a favorite for women who want quality pieces that mix and match effortlessly.
What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:
- Inclusive size range up to 3X
- Exclusive in-house designs
- Warm, helpful customer service
Good’s Store – East Earl
What Does This Store Provide:
Family-owned since 1957, Good’s packs aisles of conservative dresses, workwear, and plain accessories alongside everyday essentials. It’s a one-stop shop for shoppers who need affordable, no-frills clothing that meets Amish and Mennonite modesty standards.
What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:
- Extensive family selection from infants to adults
- Authentic plain-wear and cape dresses
- Consistently low prices
Ruthie’s Apparel
What Does This Store Provide:
Bright colors, USA-made labels, and carefully chosen accessories give Ruthie’s a fun vibe while staying modest-friendly. Shoppers love the mix of classic staples and seasonal trends that make outfit-building painless.
What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:
- USA-made and Canadian brands
- Fresh, trendy modest tops
- Personalized style advice
Plain & Fancy Country Store
What Does This Store Provide:
Inside this 5,000-sq-ft barn you’ll find Amish-made bonnets, cape dresses, and accessories alongside local crafts and baked goods. It’s ideal for visitors wanting genuine Lancaster County attire or souvenirs that celebrate plain living.
What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:
- Authentic Amish-made garments
- Wide range of bonnets and prayer caps
- One-stop souvenir shopping
Amish Mennonite Dress
What Does This Store Provide:
Sandra’s workshop offers one-of-a-kind, handmade cape dresses and accessories for the entire family, stitched by local Anabaptist artisans. Custom sizing and vibrant fabrics make it a hidden gem for serious modest-wear enthusiasts.
What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:
- Hand-sewn cape dresses
- Personalized custom sizing
- Rich, unique color palette
Find A Modest Clothing Store In A City Near Lancaster
Reading, PA Lebanon, PA York, PA Harrisburg, PA Allentown, PA Philadelphia, PA
Affiliate Disclosure: "As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases made from links in this post. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com."