Finding modest clothing in Columbus doesn’t have to feel like a scavenger hunt. Below you’ll discover every brick-and-mortar shop in town that stocks coverage-minded fashions—from curated downtown boutiques to bargain-friendly thrift stops—so you can build a wardrobe that honors your values without leaving Bartholomew County.
Browse Modest Clothing Stores in Columbus
Boutique Elise
What Does This Store Provide:
Boutique Elise curates midi dresses, long skirts, and layering basics that keep hemlines modest while staying on trend. Racks run Small–3X, making it a reliable stop for church outfits or weekday workwear.
What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:
- Friendly mother-daughter team
- Fresh weekly arrivals
- Inclusive S-3X sizing
Minash Boutique
What Does This Store Provide:
Minash’s mother-and-daughter team handpicks classy denim, flowy blouses, and modest-length sundresses from brands like Free People and Z Supply—balancing trend and coverage for women who want style without compromise.
What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:
- Well-edited brand mix
- Helpful personal styling
- Frequent sale racks
XO by Sophia’s
What Does This Store Provide:
Specializing in prom and pageant gowns, XO by Sophia’s stocks higher necklines, full skirts, and sleeve options, plus modest inserts and jackets for extra coverage.
What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:
- Wide size range up to 24W
- On-site alterations for modest tweaks
- Warm, confidence-building staff
Cato Fashions
What Does This Store Provide:
Cato offers affordable skirts, cardigans, and dresses that hit below the knee, plus a dedicated plus-size section. New shipments arrive weekly, so modest basics are easy to snag on a budget.
What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:
- Consistent under-$40 pricing
- Everyday Bible-study ready essentials
- Extended plus sizes
Burlington
What Does This Store Provide:
This discount giant carries national labels in midi skirts, maxi dresses, and layering cardigans—perfect for families dressing modestly on a budget.
What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:
- Deep markdowns on name brands
- Large coat selection for all seasons
- Spacious fitting rooms
Cupcake! Upscale Resale Boutique
What Does This Store Provide:
This upscale resale shop rotates gently-used designer finds—think modest blouses, long denim, and occasion dresses—letting you refresh your closet sustainably and affordably.
What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:
- Gently-used designer finds
- Clean, boutique-style layout
- Thoughtful owner tips on styling
Goodwill Retail Store
What Does This Store Provide:
Goodwill’s massive location lets you build a complete modest wardrobe for the cost of a single new dress, while funding local job-training programs.
What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:
- Huge dress rack turnover daily
- Prices starting under $5
- Mission-driven community impact
Sans Souci Thrift Store
What Does This Store Provide:
Operating since 1979, Sans Souci offers low-cost clothing and a voucher program for neighbors in need. Racks are neatly sorted, making it easy to find long skirts, blazers, and modest tops.
What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:
- Well-organized sections
- Supportive community programs
- Saturday markdown events
Nirvana
What Does This Store Provide:
Nirvana offers relaxed-fit jeans, modest-friendly streetwear tops, and accessories—ideal for teens and young adults who want to stay trendy without sacrificing coverage.
What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:
- Trendy yet coverage-minded
- Affordable bundle deals
- Friendly local vibe
Find A Modest Clothing Store In A City Near Columbus
Franklin, IN Seymour, IN Greenwood, IN Bloomington, IN Indianapolis, IN Carmel, IN
Affiliate Disclosure: "As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases made from links in this post. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com."