Modest Clothing Stores In Garden City, New York

Garden City proves you don’t need to leave Nassau County to build a polished, modest wardrobe. Below you’ll find four local modest-friendly boutiques—from chic lifestyle shops to size-inclusive fashion houses—each ready to help you dress with confidence and class.

Browse Modest Clothing Stores in Garden City

RUSE

Address: 51 New Hyde Park Rd, Garden City, NY 11530
Phone: 516-305-4657
Store Hours: Mon 12:30 PM–6 PM; Tue–Sat 10 AM–6 PM; Sun 11 AM–4 PM
Store Type: Trend-forward Boutique

What Does This Store Provide:

RUSE curates midi dresses, maxi skirts, and elevated basics that keep hems low and style high. Its youthful vibe makes it a go-to for students and young professionals who want runway-inspired looks without compromising modesty.


What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:

  • Fresh drops of longline dresses every week
  • Helpful staff who suggest event-ready modest looks
  • Inclusive size range from XS to XL
Visit Website

Sugarplum

Address: 181 7th St, Garden City, NY 11530
Phone: 516-887-4334
Store Hours: Mon–Fri 11 AM–6 PM; Sat 10 AM–5:30 PM; Sun 11 AM–5 PM
Store Type: Formalwear & Special-Occasion Boutique

What Does This Store Provide:

Sugarplum has dressed mothers-of-the-bride and gala guests for more than forty years. Floor-length gowns, cocktail jackets, and modest sleeves dominate its racks—perfect for guests who need elegance without excess skin.


What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:

  • Extensive line of sleeved evening gowns
  • On-site alterations for flawless coverage
  • Long-standing reputation for personal service
Visit Website

Madison’s Niche

Address: 186 7th St, Garden City, NY 11530
Phone: 516-246-9964
Store Hours: Mon–Sat 10 AM–6 PM; Sun 10 AM–5 PM
Store Type: Lifestyle Boutique

What Does This Store Provide:

This locally loved boutique blends relaxed coastal style with modest sensibilities—think midi shirt-dresses, flowy blouses, and soft cardigans. Beyond clothing you’ll find tasteful gifts and home décor, making it easy to refresh more than just your wardrobe.


What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:

  • Rotating selection of loose-fit apparel
  • Beautiful gift-ready accessories
  • Inviting, well-curated store atmosphere
Visit Website

J.Jill – Roosevelt Field

Address: 630 Old Country Rd, Space 2065B, Garden City, NY 11530
Phone: 516-408-7802
Store Hours: Mon–Thu 10 AM–8 PM; Fri 10 AM–9 PM; Sat 10 AM–9 PM; Sun 11 AM–7 PM
Store Type: Size-Inclusive Casualwear Boutique

What Does This Store Provide:

Known for its soft fabrics and forgiving cuts, J.Jill carries tunic-length tops, linen maxi skirts, and layering shells that keep everything covered. Extended petite and women’s sizing ensures every customer can build a modest capsule wardrobe that feels effortless.


What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:

  • Wide range of petite and women’s sizes
  • Breathable natural fabrics ideal for layering
  • Friendly stylists offering wardrobe guidance
Visit Website

Affiliate Disclosure: "As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases made from links in this post. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com."