Hilliard may be small, yet its mix of modest clothing stores is big on choice. Whether you’re looking for flowing abayas, size‑inclusive denim, or long‑sleeve Western wear, the shops below make it simple to dress with confidence and stay true to your values.
Browse Modest Clothing Stores in Hilliard, Ohio
Malimar Clothing
What Does This Store Provide:
This family‑run boutique focuses on premium abayas, hijabs, prayer outfits, and swimwear designed for full coverage without sacrificing style. It’s ideal for shoppers seeking high‑quality Islamic fashion at accessible prices.
What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:
- Premium abaya fabrics that drape beautifully
- Wide range of breathable hijabs
- Helpful, responsive service—online and in‑store
Uptown Cheapskate – Hilliard
What Does This Store Provide:
Uptown Cheapskate buys and sells gently‑used name‑brand apparel. Racks are organized by category and length, making it easy to spot midi skirts, maxi dresses, and layering pieces perfectly suited to modest wardrobes.
What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:
- Everyday savings on popular labels
- Well‑lit fitting rooms for easy layering
- Friendly staff that sorts by silhouette and trend
Good Life Thriftstore
What Does This Store Provide:
This non‑profit thrift store offers ever‑changing racks of second‑hand skirts, dresses, and tops—perfect for budget‑friendly modest closets. Proceeds support children’s ministries abroad, so every purchase does double good.
What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:
- Constant new arrivals with longer hemlines
- Monthly discount days up to 50 % off
- Roomy aisles for relaxed browsing
The Urban Market
What Does This Store Provide:
The Urban Market curates on‑trend basics, soft knit cardigans, and size‑inclusive styles up to 3X. It’s a great stop for modest shoppers who love modern silhouettes without plunging necklines or super‑short hems.
What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:
- Inclusive size range S–3X
- Plenty of coverage‑friendly layers
- Owner‑led focus on quality fabrics
The Happy Closet Boutique
What Does This Store Provide:
This downtown boutique handpicks flattering pieces—especially Judy Blue jeans—and easy‑fit tops that keep you covered without sacrificing flair. Pop‑up events and after‑hours appointments create a relaxed, community feel.
What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:
- Ultra‑stretchy Judy Blue denim
- Curated mix‑and‑match modest looks
- Fun mystery‑bag sales
Boot Barn
What Does This Store Provide:
Boot Barn stocks long denim skirts, prairie‑style dresses, and sturdy work shirts that layer well for extra coverage. Western flair meets practicality, making it a favorite for modest dressers who love a country vibe.
What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:
- Extended‑length western dresses
- Durable workwear perfect for layering
- Loyalty rewards and military discount
Discount Fashion Warehouse (DFWH)
What Does This Store Provide:
DFWH carries brand‑name overstock—often 60–90 % off retail—including modest‑friendly maxi dresses, cardigans, and long skirts. It’s a treasure trove for shoppers who love a bargain but still want coverage.
What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:
- Huge overstock discounts
- Frequent racks of lined maxi dresses
- Generous return policy on unworn items
Old Navy – Market@Hilliard
What Does This Store Provide:
Known for inclusive sizing and budget‑friendly basics, Old Navy is a go‑to for layering tees, tall‑length cardigans, and midi dresses that fit a modest lifestyle while keeping the whole family coordinated.
What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:
- Affordable classic tees and cardigans
- Tall, petite, and plus size options
- Regular sales on wardrobe staples
Find A Modest Clothing Store In A City Near Hilliard
Columbus, Ohio Dublin, Ohio Upper Arlington, Ohio Grove City, Ohio Delaware, Ohio Westerville, Ohio
Affiliate Disclosure: "As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases made from links in this post. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com."