Ithaca may be known for gorges and college life, yet the city is also home to a handful of modest-minded boutiques where longer hemlines, easy layers, and conscience-friendly fabrics are the norm. Below you’ll find every brick-and-mortar spot in town that helps you dress with grace—no online guesswork required.
Browse Modest Clothing Stores in Ithaca
Say Goodbye to Pinch and Poke: Welcome God-Given Comfort with the Seamless Wave Bra
Ever catch yourself tugging at a wired bra halfway through the day and whispering, “Lord, set me free”? This feather-light, underwire-free Wave Bra answers that prayer with a smooth silhouette that glides under tees, Sunday best, and everything in between. Its clever W-shaped support lifts from every angle while semi-fixed padding keeps you naturally rounded—no shifting, no fuss. Wide side panels tame those underarm troubles, adjustable crossable straps let you find your just-right fit, and four easy hooks lock it all in place so you can raise your hands in worship, work, or play without a single poke. Crafted from a soft polyamide-spandex blend that feels like a second skin, this bra is the quiet ally every daughter of God deserves because true confidence starts with comfort you never have to think about.
Feel Goods Ithaca
What Does This Store Provide:
Curated racks feature natural-fiber dresses, roomy skirts, and vintage pieces that keep shoulders covered without sacrificing style. The shop highlights small U.S. makers, so you can build a thoughtful, modest wardrobe while supporting ethical production.
What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:
- Sustainable fabrics that feel good against the skin
- Inclusive size range and friendly styling tips
- Creative workshops that teach sewing and up-cycling
Petrune
What Does This Store Provide:
Petrune’s hand-picked vintage dresses, blouses, and high-waist trousers give modest fashion fans classic silhouettes plus one-of-a-kind flair. Their staff loves pairing retro finds with modern layers to create outfits that cover yet still pop.
What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:
- Carefully cleaned, quality vintage pieces
- Helpful styling advice for mixing eras
- Late-evening hours on weekends
Opportunity Boutique
What Does This Store Provide:
Run by the Women’s Opportunity Center, the boutique offers gently used blazers, dresses, and skirts ideal for work or church—proceeds fund career-training programs for local women. Shopping here lets you dress modestly and empower neighbors at the same time.
What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:
- Budget-friendly prices that stretch any wallet
- Mission-driven shopping that supports women’s futures
- Plenty of professional attire for interviews
Trader K’s
What Does This Store Provide:
As one of New York’s largest indie resale shops, Trader K’s stocks everything from midi skirts to high-neck blouses—perfect for modest wardrobes—at thrift-store prices. Trade in your unused items for credit and refresh your closet sustainably.
What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:
- Huge selection across multiple sizes
- Generous trade-in credits for gently used pieces
- Extended evening hours on weekends
LOFT – Shops at Ithaca Mall
What Does This Store Provide:
LOFT’s classic cardigans, midi dresses, and wrinkle-resistant trousers make modest dressing effortless. Their petites and plus sections ensure a flattering fit whether you’re headed to class, the office, or Sunday service.
What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:
- Frequent sales on modest basics
- Wide size range from petite to plus
- Soft fabrics that layer beautifully
Find A Modest Clothing Store In A City Near Ithaca
Elmira, NY Binghamton, NY Auburn, NY Syracuse, NY Rochester, NY Utica, NY
Affiliate Disclosure: "As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases made from links in this post. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com."