Modest Clothing Stores In Ithaca, New York

Ithaca may be known for gorges and college life, yet the city is also home to a handful of modest-minded boutiques where longer hemlines, easy layers, and conscience-friendly fabrics are the norm. Below you’ll find every brick-and-mortar spot in town that helps you dress with grace—no online guesswork required.

Browse Modest Clothing Stores in Ithaca

Feel Goods Ithaca

Address: 317 Taughannock Blvd, Ithaca, NY 14850
Phone: (607) 342-7675
Store Hours: Wed–Sat: 11 AM–6 PM; Sun: 12 PM–6 PM; Mon–Tue Closed
Store Type: Ethical Boutique

What Does This Store Provide:

Curated racks feature natural-fiber dresses, roomy skirts, and vintage pieces that keep shoulders covered without sacrificing style. The shop highlights small U.S. makers, so you can build a thoughtful, modest wardrobe while supporting ethical production.


What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:

  • Sustainable fabrics that feel good against the skin
  • Inclusive size range and friendly styling tips
  • Creative workshops that teach sewing and up-cycling
Visit Website

Petrune

Address: 128 The Commons, Ithaca, NY 14850
Phone: (607) 277-1930
Store Hours: Fri–Sat: 11 AM–8 PM; Sun–Thu: 11 AM–7 PM
Store Type: Vintage & Retro Boutique

What Does This Store Provide:

Petrune’s hand-picked vintage dresses, blouses, and high-waist trousers give modest fashion fans classic silhouettes plus one-of-a-kind flair. Their staff loves pairing retro finds with modern layers to create outfits that cover yet still pop.


What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:

  • Carefully cleaned, quality vintage pieces
  • Helpful styling advice for mixing eras
  • Late-evening hours on weekends
Visit Website

Opportunity Boutique

Address: 315 N Tioga St, Ithaca, NY 14850
Phone: (607) 272-1520
Store Hours: Mon–Fri: 10 AM–5 PM; Sat–Sun Closed
Store Type: Non-profit Modest Boutique

What Does This Store Provide:

Run by the Women’s Opportunity Center, the boutique offers gently used blazers, dresses, and skirts ideal for work or church—proceeds fund career-training programs for local women. Shopping here lets you dress modestly and empower neighbors at the same time.


What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:

  • Budget-friendly prices that stretch any wallet
  • Mission-driven shopping that supports women’s futures
  • Plenty of professional attire for interviews

Trader K’s

Address: 119 E State St, Ithaca, NY 14850
Phone: (607) 272-4011
Store Hours: Mon–Thu: 10 AM–8 PM; Fri–Sat: 10 AM–9 PM; Sun: 11 AM–6 PM
Store Type: Consignment & Resale

What Does This Store Provide:

As one of New York’s largest indie resale shops, Trader K’s stocks everything from midi skirts to high-neck blouses—perfect for modest wardrobes—at thrift-store prices. Trade in your unused items for credit and refresh your closet sustainably.


What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:

  • Huge selection across multiple sizes
  • Generous trade-in credits for gently used pieces
  • Extended evening hours on weekends
Visit Website

LOFT – Shops at Ithaca Mall

Address: 40 Catherwood Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850
Phone: (607) 257-0429
Store Hours: Mon–Sat: 10 AM–7 PM; Sun: 11 AM–5 PM
Store Type: Women’s Apparel Chain

What Does This Store Provide:

LOFT’s classic cardigans, midi dresses, and wrinkle-resistant trousers make modest dressing effortless. Their petites and plus sections ensure a flattering fit whether you’re headed to class, the office, or Sunday service.


What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:

  • Frequent sales on modest basics
  • Wide size range from petite to plus
  • Soft fabrics that layer beautifully
Visit Website

Find A Modest Clothing Store In A City Near Ithaca

Elmira, NY Binghamton, NY Auburn, NY Syracuse, NY Rochester, NY Utica, NY


Affiliate Disclosure: "As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases made from links in this post. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com."