Modest Clothing Stores In Sidney, Ohio

Sidney, Ohio may be small, yet its mix of family-friendly outlets, budget-wise thrift shops, and plus-size-savvy chains makes finding modest clothes refreshingly easy. Take a stroll down Michigan Street or pop into a church-run resale store—either way you’ll uncover skirts, longline tops, and faith-friendly fashions that keep both style and conscience intact.

Browse Modest Clothing Stores in Sidney

Cato Fashions

Address: 2280 Michigan Street, Sidney, OH 45365
Phone: (937) 492-0974
Store Hours: Mon–Sat 10 AM–7 PM; Sun 1 PM–6 PM
Store Type: Women’s Specialty Fashion (Juniors, Misses & Plus)

What Does This Store Provide:

Cato keeps modest shopping simple with knee-length dresses, relaxed-fit blouses, and plenty of extended sizes up to 28—all at wallet-friendly everyday prices. Weekly new arrivals and an easy-to-navigate layout make it ideal for busy moms and career women who want fresh looks without fuss.


What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:

  • Consistent plus-size range alongside regular sizes
  • Affordable church-ready dresses and skirts
  • Friendly team that offers quick styling tips
Visit Website

Bealls Outlet

Address: 2290 West Michigan Street, Sidney, OH 45365
Phone: (937) 498-0035
Store Hours: Mon–Thu 9 AM–9 PM; Fri–Sat 9 AM–9:30 PM; Sun 10 AM–8 PM
Store Type: Discount Department Outlet

What Does This Store Provide:

Expect name-brand modest basics—think midi skirts, high-neck tees, and layering cardigans—at up to 70 % off. The rotating racks cover the whole family, so you can score conservative looks for teens, husbands, and toddlers in one quick trip.


What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:

  • Deep markdowns on season-friendly apparel
  • Surprising curve-friendly finds in petites & plus
  • Ample clearance events for bigger savings
Visit Website

Goodwill Thrift Store

Address: 417 East Court Street, Sidney, OH 45365
Phone: (937) 498-7537
Store Hours: Mon–Sat 8 AM–9 PM; Sun 11 AM–6 PM
Store Type: Non-Profit Thrift Store

What Does This Store Provide:

With thousands of donated items hitting the floor weekly, this Goodwill is a treasure-trove for long denim skirts, maxi dresses, and loose tops at just a few dollars apiece. Every purchase fuels local job-training programs—so modest fashion meets meaningful impact.


What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:

  • Endless bargain racks refreshed daily
  • Frequent color-tag sales for extra discounts
  • Community mission that supports local families
Visit Website

F.I.S.H. Community Thrift Store

Address: 1128 West Michigan Street, Sidney, OH 45365
Phone: (937) 492-1760
Store Hours: Mon–Fri 10 AM–3 PM; Sat 10 AM–12 PM; Sun Closed
Store Type: Charity Thrift & Food-Pantry Support

What Does This Store Provide:

Operated by local volunteers, F.I.S.H. offers gently used, modest apparel at pay-what-you-can prices. Proceeds help fund emergency food and utility assistance across Shelby County—perfect for shoppers who love giving back while they browse.


What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:

  • Ultra-low price points on every rack
  • Friendly volunteer staff eager to help
  • Mission-driven community outreach
Visit Website

St. John Thrift Shop

Address: 319 South Ohio Avenue, Sidney, OH 45365
Phone: (937) 492-0337
Store Hours: Mon–Fri 10 AM–4 PM; Sat–Sun Closed
Store Type: Church-Run Thrift Boutique

What Does This Store Provide:

Run by St. John’s Lutheran volunteers, the shop curates clean, modest separates—think blazers, midi skirts, and classic blouses—alongside household gems. Weekly themed sales make it a popular stop for frugal, faith-minded shoppers.


What Shoppers Appreciate The Most:

  • Well-organized boutique-style racks
  • Regular half-price events on select tags
  • Warm, community-first atmosphere

Find A Modest Clothing Store In A City Near Sidney

Piqua, Ohio Troy, Ohio Lima, Ohio Dayton, Ohio Beavercreek, Ohio Huber Heights, Ohio


Affiliate Disclosure: "As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases made from links in this post. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com."